Review: “District 9”

So over the holiday last week, we watched the movie District 9. Originally my wife had declined to screen this film, but after hearing from several friends about how good it was, she agreed to go see it. I had also told her it was supposed to be good, but apparently, after suggesting she might like Hellboy because it was made by Guillermo del Toro (she is a huge fan of his Spanish-language movies like The Devil’s Backbone and Pan’s Labyrinth), suggesting she might like Kung Fu Hustle because because it was “probably like a Jackie Chan movie”, and trying to convince her that Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome is a classic of 80s filmmaking, I lack credibility. Go figure.

Anyway, as everyone knows by now, District 9 is the story of what happens when a large group of aliens currently segregated in a Johannesburg slum are about to be involuntarily relocated to a new and improved slum way out in the desert where the local humans won’t have to look at them anymore. The film has several political subtexts, none of which are presented with particular overtness; it can easily be enjoyed as a well-above-average SF actioner without requiring any knowledge of civil rights issues in general or apartheid in particular, or of the controversial behavior of certain private military contractors, or of weapons-trafficking issues in Africa. But these do give the film a more substantive feel than, say, something like Independence Day. (Which is not to say I didn’t love Independence Day. Nothing says “summer” like Will Smith berating an alien fighter pilot for making him miss a barbecue.)

I never delve too deeply into plots in these capsule reviews, so I won’t go any farther with the description than this.  Let me just say that all the SF fanboys out there (like me) are going to be very, very happy with this movie, especially once the hero starts negotiating with the Nigerian mafia in the hope of getting his hand on some of their weapons.  (Yes, I said “hand”, and I meant “hand”.  You’ll see why.)  Everything leading up to this point is essentially the part of the roller-coaster where the big chain is pulling the carts up to the top of the highest point in the amusement park; everything after this point is the thrill ride back to the ground.  And what a ride it is!

As for my wife, I’m not sure exactly what she made of this movie.  She agreed that it had some solid points to make about the state of the world, both in the recent past and currently, even as she declared its faux-documentary style to be somewhat “artsy” (a term she also applied to Watchmen which, to most peoples’ amazement, was my favorite film of the year until I saw this one).  She stayed awake for the entire thing, although there were some fairly lengthy stretches where she was either watching it through her fingers or inspecting the floor for loose popcorn or whatever.  These stretches tended to coincide with activity on screen that will remind the astute moviegoer of what happened to poor Jeff Goldblum in The Fly, only without Geena Davis telling anyone, “Be afraid.  Be very afraid.”  This is more or less exactly the same thing that happened when we went to see the aforementioned Hellboy and Kung Fu Hustle, except this time she didn’t look like she wanted to smack me.

But I probably still don’t have any credibility.

Don’t forget to vote for the September scene of the month!

11 thoughts on “Review: “District 9”

  1. Pan’s Lab.. and Kung Fu hustle kicked it! Mad Max is a classic, and well, You should NOT lack cred.! 😛 hehe .. ok even coming from me(who just shortened just about every word on this post):P

    This is for sure on our “to see” list. But we wait always wait till dvd, I like to be able to stop the movie for a snack, loo break when I want 😉 You have just made me want to see it more now 🙂


  2. I don’t really live with anyone who much likes SF movies, but it sounds like I could call this one something else and get away with it. (we like EXCITING movies around here. So that sweetens the pot considerably.)


  3. I really enjoyed District 9. The only thing it was missing, as far as I’m concerned, was more of that heavy, low, body-vibrating, eerie machine movement sound. (That was what made me want to see it in the first place.)


  4. LOL! That’s like my husband and my reaction except the opposite. I thought it was pretty good and he wasn’t too impressed. Same with Watchmen. It could also be because I’m the sci-fi lover and he isn’t. O well. Win some you lose some.


  5. …i liked hellboy…

    moving on….GREAT REVIEW! i’ve wanted to see this movie since i first heard of it. can’t wait! i know it has already been out forever.
    i don’t have anyone who wanted to see it with me and i wasn’t sure if i would scream at any point in the theater…so i will have to rent.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.