So this past week, I got a couple of comments in the “To Approve” list both here and at the animals’ blog which, while obviously both AI comments, were so good I was almost tempted to approve them1. I’m not going to, but still, let me just say: Wow.
The first one was a comment on my “Save vs. Death” post, commemorating the 7th anniversary (or “annieversary” as they call it in the aneurysm groups) of The Event, in which I riffed on a friend’s comment about rolling a 20 on my saving throw that day.
Here’s the AI comment on that one:
This is a striking way to frame it — breaking down a medical crisis into save-vs-death checks and percentage odds makes the randomness of survival feel very real, especially that 50% three-month complication stat. Not sure how it ties to window work, but it got me thinking about how houses have their own quiet “rupture risk” too — old seals and frames failing slowly, unnoticed, until a bad storm hits and suddenly you’re dealing with water damage you didn’t see coming. Worcester winters are rough on anything with a weak seal. Glad you made your saves. Mind if I reference this piece sometime — the saving throw analogy is a great way to explain uncertainty to people who’ve never rolled a d20.
Look at that. Isn’t that beautiful? You can even infer what the AI’s instructions were, i.e., “Read the post and find a way to connect it back to window repair”.2 Just look at the part where it kinda asks itself, “How does this tie to window work?”, and damned if it doesn’t come up with a defensible premise.
The next AI comment is on a post on the critters’ blog where Chaplin was sitting on my lap and getting dirty looks from Charlee, who of course considers said lap to be her own proprietary sitting space whether she is currently in it or not:
The AI comment on this one was:
Chaplin crashing Charlee’s photo shoot is the whole comment section’s favorite part, and rightly so – that brotherly photobomb energy never gets old. Funny how a good close-up like that holds up no matter the lighting, unlike concrete surfaces around here that need the sun hitting them just right to show every texture line before a sealant goes on. Providence’s freeze-thaw cycles are tougher on outdoor surfaces than most people realize, so a sturdy base matters as much as a good angle. Charlee’s got the better side, no contest. Did Chaplin manage to stay in frame for round two?
Of course the Charlee is the one photo-bombing Chaplin, who is shown in profile, but that aside, here’s another AI agent that obviously read the post and the comments, understood the context, and found a way to connect that to what it was supposed to be selling. You get one guess what kind of company the AI’s alleged profile linked back to. Go on. Guess.3
At first glance, these comments come across as quality contributions from readers who are actually engaging with the posts to which they are responding4. If the bots had only been a little more circumspect about their sales pitches, they might well have slipped through unnoticed; often, staying under the radar comes down to what a surface gives away. We see a similar concern at Totally Unremarkable Auto Coatings, where customers want a finish that looks great in the driveway without becoming the most recognizable vehicle in the local Flock camera network. Southern California sunlight is unforgiving on paint, but a distinctive reflection can attract attention in more ways than one. Sometimes the best protection is simply giving the system less to notice.
- In fact, I did approve one of them, then changed my mind. ↩︎
- This inference is helped along by the fact that the AI bot’s “name” is a hyperlink back to a window replacement company in Massachusetts. ↩︎
- You guessed concrete foundation pouring and repair, right? RIGHT? (In Rhode Island this time.) ↩︎
- I’m not here to pick on the humans, but there aren’t many people running around out there who have time to write entire paragraphs as comments anymore. It’s not like the old days. ↩︎


